• Laws
  • News

Can You Sue A Psychic? How To Defeat Fortune In Court


Each year, millions of Americans seek the services of palmists, mediums, psychics, and other people who assert supernatural talents.

While most people view these activities as harmless fun to be taken lightly, there are others who firmly hold this belief. As a consequence, they frequently lose thousands of dollars before realizing they have been taken advantage of. As a result, many people begin to wonder if there are any laws that govern psychics and if anybody can sue a psychic.

Most claims made against psychics do not center on suffering or harm brought on by "wrong forecasts." For years, psychic Sylvia Browne appeared weekly on American television, informing families that lost loved ones were dead when they weren't, or living when they weren't.

After looking closely at all 115 of her predictions, it was clear that Browne was right not once, not twice, but not once at all. She was only found guilty of grand theft for fraudulently selling shares in a gold mine, not for being a bogus psychic.

Can You Sue A Psychic?

COPYRIGHT_LNN: Published on https://www.lawnewsnetwork.com/sue-a-psychic/ by - on 2023-01-15T16:37:48.935Z

It is legal to sue a psychic. However, courts frequently lack empathy for clients who are unsatisfied with occult and spiritual services.

Anyone can practice as a psychic, medium, crystal gazer, or anything else; there are no educational requirements or industry standards. It is absolutely subjective to determine what works and does not work. Court decisions are based on logic and proof.

Giving bad guidance or unethical counsel is not illegal. Lawsuits are about money spent by clients who didn't get what they paid for, not about morals or bad forecasts. Or they deal with excessively pushy billing and marketing. They must include money in some manner or another.

What Laws Apply To Psychics?

Despite frequently not being as strictly regulated as other businesses or professions, psychics are nevertheless bound by a number of regulations. For example, most places require psychics to have a license before they can charge for their services.

They also have to pay taxes on the money they make from their services, and in a few cases, they have to go through background checks and licensing exams.

Of course, it can be difficult to regulate a sector that considers itself supernatural and beyond the comprehension of modern science, has no set educational criteria, but nevertheless charges for its services.

Some psychics claim that what they do is truly a type of religion and that their income should be recognized in the same way as gifts to other religious institutions.

Some claim to be nothing more than entertainers and even publish disclaimers to that effect in an effort to put themselves beyond any cost or harm a client could incur as a result of following a psychic's advice.

Still, according to Joynumber, roughly 30 million Americans (or about 1 in 7) sought the advice of a psychic or other kind of fortune teller in 2009. As a result, the psychic services market in the US is worth several million dollars annually.

Spread Cards on the Table
Spread Cards on the Table

The Court Cases That Made Psychics Pay

In one of the two most well-known "psychic" lawsuits, the court decided against Psychic Friends Network, a pioneering phone-psychic business, not because customers complained that their "readings" were inaccurate or unsatisfactory, but rather because of its billing procedures. It was a significant earner in the 1990s until going bankrupt in 1998.

The Federal Trade Commission closed down another psychic network in the United States run by "Miss Cleo" because it advertised free phone readings even though they could cost up to $100 per call, misled customers into thinking they had to pay when they didn't, and engaged in aggressive and even abusive telemarketing.

Customers who owed millions of dollars to "Miss Cleo's" business, including $44.3 million in Florida alone, had to have their debts forgiven and the damage to their credit scores fixed.

Called themselves "America's Psychic." Sean David Morton filed a lawsuit in an effort to put an end to an SEC investigation that resulted in civil fraud accusations against him and his wife.

The two reportedly conned 100 investors out of $6 million by promising them Morton's stock market prognostication skills. The money was not invested as promised, and thus the SEC sued him rather than him for lying.

As a consequence, Morton's side did not cooperate, and the SEC prevailed in a summary judgment. Some of the private plaintiffs who filed cases against the Morton family were successful.

Many victims of fraud are too ashamed to file a lawsuit. Others will be pleased to have their money back, while some will just accept the loss.

Restitution is typically only partial. Due to the inclusion of psychic frauds in Great Britain's consumer protection law in 2008, the phrase "for amusement only" can now be seen on a lot of websites, serving as a protective barrier for the majority of internet, mobile, and telephone psychics.

U.S. consumer law allows you to sue a con artist, but the maximum amount of your settlement is often capped at three times what you spent.

When trying to get their money back, some people are unsuccessful. 2013 saw a British guy fall in love with his psychic, who foretold their impending nuptials.

After divorcing his wife and selling everything he owned to pay the psychic, the guy discovered he had been duped after almost a year.

He did everything he could to expose her fraud and destroy her business, but he was unable to recover his money. He was accused of harassing the psychic. In this case, the judge sided with the guy, who went back to his wife.

Chances Of Winning

A lawsuit against a psychic is unlikely to succeed. You might have a case if you can demonstrate that a psychic misled you into believing your husband didn't have cancer when, in fact, he did, that she presented that information as fact and an expert opinion, that her reading contributed to his death, and that his death resulted in quantifiable losses for you.

Of course, this assumes you can convince a lawyer to take the case. The courts and almost everyone else will undoubtedly inquire as to why you sought the advice of a psychic rather than a doctor regarding your ailing husband and will likely draw the conclusion that it was you, not the psychic, who acted irresponsibly.

The subtle distinctions that occult and religious practitioners make do not matter in court since laws vary everywhere.

For instance, until 2013, "fortunetelling" was forbidden in St. Louis, Missouri; therefore, nearby psychic fairs and New Age stores remained outside the city's boundaries. Tarot cards and tea leaves are both considered to be forms of "fortunetelling."

One may debate for hours that astrology and palmistry are not only "fortunetelling," which is a pejorative word in the esoteric community, but rather both an art and a science. However, they are all equal in the eyes of the law.

Hand Signing in Documentation Paper
Hand Signing in Documentation Paper

People Also Ask

Is Fortune Telling A Crime In New York?

Unbelievably, according to New York's penal code, fortune-telling is illegal. Penal Law Section 165.35 specifically defines fortune telling as a crime.Although fortune telling is not always illegal, both New York State and federal authorities will investigate fortune-telling fraud.

Is Fortune Telling Illegal In California?

In 1985, the state Supreme Court overturned regulations that expressly prohibited fortunetelling in numerous California cities, including Los Angeles and San Francisco. However, some localities still have regulations in place that prohibit the practice.

This exception is allowed because fortune-telling might be a form of free speech, which is protected by both the federal and Florida state constitutions.


If you think a psychic has harmed you, you might want to speak with both local police authorities and an attorney. Due to the sometimes unregulated nature of psychic work, it may be hard to sue a psychic. However, laws against fraud and other types of deceit may allow someone to get some kind of justice.

Share: Twitter | Facebook | Linkedin

Recent Articles

  • How Does The Legal System In Kenya Work?


    How Does The Legal System In Kenya Work?

    The Republic of Kenya is a democratic, unitary state with national and county levels of administration. The Fourth Schedule of the Constitution outlines each level's unique responsibilities, which include a legal system in Kenya overseen by the Supreme Court and legislative authority controlled by a Congress.

  • Use Of Science In Courtroom For Judgements


    Use Of Science In Courtroom For Judgements

    In this age of science, science should expect a warm welcome and maybe even a permanent place in our courts. More and more, science in courtroom concepts and methods are being used in the court cases we are currently facing.

  • War Correspondent Protection In International Law


    War Correspondent Protection In International Law

    They discuss the protection to which they are entitled as non-combatants under international humanitarian law, according to LNN and KICK legal experts. In this article they review the status of war correspondent international laws.

  • Medical Laws All Doctors Should Know


    Medical Laws All Doctors Should Know

    Most doctors are not attorneys. But that doesn't imply they have to be completely ignorant of the medical laws.

  • Best Lawyers Series Ever Made For TV That You Should Watch


    Best Lawyers Series Ever Made For TV That You Should Watch

    These days, there are so many in-depth lawyers series on TV that watching them could make someone feel like they are a lawyer. There are many excellent legal dramas that focus on a new case every week, but the very best legal dramas are the ones that go above and beyond the procedural expectations of the genre and take some big chances.

  • Is Selling Diamonds Illegal? - Determin If It Is A Safe Business Venture


    Is Selling Diamonds Illegal? - Determin If It Is A Safe Business Venture

    You may be wondering whether it is selling diamonds illegal?. In a nutshell, the answer is that you can sell your diamonds legally. However, you might be curious about how your diamond is evaluated and what factors exactly determine its worth.

  • Right Of Publicity - Legal View On Publicity For Celebrities


    Right Of Publicity - Legal View On Publicity For Celebrities

    A right of publicity is the right to decide how your name, likeness, voice, signature, or other things that are unique to you can be used in business.

  • Pornography Laws Washington - What Types Are Forbidden In The State?


    Pornography Laws Washington - What Types Are Forbidden In The State?

    While some forms of pornography are unlawful in Washington, we'll focus on two specific instances: child pornography and revenge pornography, both of which are against the pornography laws washington.

  • Knee Replacement Lawsuit Statute Of Limitations - Claims And Settlements


    Knee Replacement Lawsuit Statute Of Limitations - Claims And Settlements

    If you are interested to know more about knee replacement lawsuit statute of limitations, then you are in the right place. According to knee replacement lawsuits, the devices loosened and became unstable, necessitating revision surgery to correct the issues. Knee implants named in lawsuits include Depuy Attune, Zimmer NexGen, and Arthrex iBalance. Sulzer Medica paid $1 billion to settle 4,000 hip and knee implant cases in the largest knee replacement lawsuit settlement.

  • Risperdal Lawsuit Update 2022 - Response To Alleged Risperdal Harm

  • Bard Hernia Mesh Lawsuit Update 2022 - The Lawsuit Against C.R. Bard

  • Rhode Island Hernia Mesh Bellwether Lawsuit - Jury Awarded $4.8M

  • Top 5 Free Law Internships For High School Students

  • Brazilian Civil Code And Obligation Of In Laws Towards Elderly People