• Laws
  • News

Selective Liability - Is There A Real Choice?


Selective liability means acting as if there was a real choice between fault-based and strict liability legal systems, to look into what seems to be a deal between online selling platforms and sellers to make it easy for them to avoid blame.

The paper looked at the problems with prosecuting traders who use online auction sites to sell ivory in violation of "cites" rules. It did this by analyzing data about online trading.

To keep track of sales over the course of 90 days, three other names for ivory were found: antique bovine bone, antique cow bone, and antique Chinese cow bone.

The results showed that sellers are using these euphemisms to sell ivory online. These results also showed that a company's ban on selling ivory is at odds with how easy it seems to be to sell ivory through a website.

What Is Selective Liability?

COPYRIGHT_LNN: Published on https://www.lawnewsnetwork.com/selective-liability/ by - on 2022-10-05T00:29:39.471Z

Research Futures: Selective Liability in the ivory trade

In the criminal world, liability means being responsible for a crime and the punishment that society gives for that crime. A defendant can be found guilty of a crime if the prosecution can show that they did the illegal act and had the criminal intent (mens rea) to do so.

For example, a defendant could be found guilty of theft if they stole something from a victim with the intent to take it away from the victim forever.

"Selective liability" is the behavior of people who use online auction platforms as if they had a real choice between fault-based (in which the plaintiff must prove that the defendant's behavior was either negligent or intentional).

Strict liability (in which a person is legally responsible for the results of action even if the defendant did not do anything wrong or have criminal intent) legal systems.

On online auction sites, guns and Nazi memorabilia aren't usually sold openly like ivory is.

This makes it seem like there must be times when a seller of an illegal item changes their behavior so that it fits with the legal responsibility for a strict liability offense, even though it is not a strict liability offense in law.

Selective Liability Balance

To move the balance of selective liability further toward a corporate response more in line with acting as if strict liability applied, regulators and environmental conservation groups could make negative consumer sentiment more visible and make the most of it.

There are many bad effects of a wild animal trade that isn't well run, such as zoonotic virus pandemics like COVID-19 (Zhou et al., 2020).

So, pointing out this connection in a legal way could help convince online auction sites to stop letting people sell illegal wildlife products. In the underground world of the illegal wildlife trade, when one door closes, another one will always open.

But if eBay and other online sales platforms are willing to do what it takes and have the technology and money to keep investing in screening tools, they are largely the ones who can stop the online sale of ivory.

People Also Ask

What Is Comprehensive General Liability?

Comprehensive General Liability coverage protects against claims of injuries to people or damage to property caused by a contractor or tenant's work.

This kind of policy covers premises and operations, the use of independent contractors, and products and operations that are already done.

What Does Comprehensive Personal Liability Cover?

Comprehensive Personal Liability is usually found in section II of a homeowner's insurance policy. It covers things like premises, personal activities, pets, some contracts, and certain incidental coverages when it comes to personal liability.

What Is The Difference Between General Liability And Commercial General Liability?

General liability insurance (GLI) helps pay for claims that your business hurt someone or damaged their property. Commercial general liability insurance is another name for this coverage (CGL).

You can get GLI as a separate policy or as part of a Business Owner's Policy that includes other important coverages (BOP).


The term "selective liability" refers to how some participants in online auctions act as though they have a real choice between fault-based and strict liability legal regimes.

Share: Twitter | Facebook | Linkedin

Recent Articles

  • Knee Replacement Lawsuit Statute Of Limitations - Claims And Settlements


    Knee Replacement Lawsuit Statute Of Limitations - Claims And Settlements

    If you are interested to know more about knee replacement lawsuit statute of limitations, then you are in the right place. According to knee replacement lawsuits, the devices loosened and became unstable, necessitating revision surgery to correct the issues. Knee implants named in lawsuits include Depuy Attune, Zimmer NexGen, and Arthrex iBalance. Sulzer Medica paid $1 billion to settle 4,000 hip and knee implant cases in the largest knee replacement lawsuit settlement.

  • Risperdal Lawsuit Update 2022 - Response To Alleged Risperdal Harm


    Risperdal Lawsuit Update 2022 - Response To Alleged Risperdal Harm

    We already have the Risperdal lawsuit update 2022. Thousands of men and their families across the United States began filing lawsuits in response to alleged Risperdal harm. The plaintiffs claim they were not adequately warned that taking the medication could result in a noticeable increase in breast tissue (called gynecomastia). Risperdal has been linked to an increased risk of developing excess breast tissue, according to research. Those who have filed lawsuits claim they were not given any prior notice.

  • Bard Hernia Mesh Lawsuit Update 2022 - The Lawsuit Against C.R. Bard


    Bard Hernia Mesh Lawsuit Update 2022 - The Lawsuit Against C.R. Bard

    People are interested regarding the Bard Hernia Mesh lawsuit update 2022. C.R. Bard is defending over 16,000 hernia mesh lawsuits alleging that its mesh devices were defective and caused thousands of hernia surgery patients to suffer injuries and complications. Hernia mesh attorneys handle claims in all 50 states. This post will provide news and updates on the C.R. Bard hernia mesh lawsuit, as well as an update on the current status of the Bard hernia mesh class-action MDL as of September 26, 2022, following the new $4.8 million C.R. Bard verdict in Rhode Island state court.

  • Rhode Island Hernia Mesh Bellwether Lawsuit - Jury Awarded $4.8M


    Rhode Island Hernia Mesh Bellwether Lawsuit - Jury Awarded $4.8M

    On Monday, a jury in a state court in Rhode Island reached a verdict in the amount of $4.8 million dollars about the Rhode Island hernia mesh bellwether lawsuit. This is the first state court trial in the country involving allegedly defective hernia mesh implants. The trial took place in Rhode Island. Plaintiff Paul Trevino's attorney, Jonathan Orent of Motley Rice LLC, told Courtroom View Network that the jury awarded him $4.8 million, which he claims will increase to $7.68 million with interest.

  • Top 5 Free Law Internships For High School Students


    Top 5 Free Law Internships For High School Students

    Participating in high school law internships and other programs with a legal focus will help you get ready for your future job if you're a high school student interested in becoming a lawyer. You can experience legal careers before you even enroll in college thanks to law internships for high school students, summer programs, and volunteer opportunities.

  • Brazilian Civil Code And Obligation Of In Laws Towards Elderly People


    Brazilian Civil Code And Obligation Of In Laws Towards Elderly People

    According to the Brazilian civil code and obligation of in laws towards elderly, the elderly must not face any form of prejudice, and their offspring must take care of them as they get older. The "Estatuto do Idoso" (Elderly Statute) and the "Polictica Nacional de Sade do Idoso" are the two protection systems in place in Brazil (National Health Policy for the Elderly). Seniors have the following rights:

  • United States V. Microsoft - What Happened To The Case?


    United States V. Microsoft - What Happened To The Case?

    Whether the Stored Communications Act lets warrants be issued for personal information that is stored outside of the U.S. United States v. Microsoft is a case that was heard by the U.S. Supreme Court in October 2017. On February 27, 2018, there was a hearing about the case.

  • Federal Weed Law - For Medical Purposes Only


    Federal Weed Law - For Medical Purposes Only

    To date (2022 April), 18 states have legalized marijuana for recreational use, while another 37 allow its usage for medical purposes. When it came to legalizing medical marijuana, California was the trailblazer in 1996. Federal Weed still makes possession of any amount of marijuana a crime.

  • Antitrust - America’s Efforts To Smash Anticompetitive Practices


    Antitrust - America’s Efforts To Smash Anticompetitive Practices

    One of the many ways the U.S. government ensures that business competition will thrive - and in a fair way - in the country is to enforce its antitrust laws. It already lost one fight too many against monopolies and unfair and unlawful business practices. However, the government also triumphed several times, and shall continue the battle.

  • Voting Rights Challenged - Latest Race Discrimination In Alabama

  • Trump Asks U.S. Supreme Court To Intervene Over Seized Classified Documents

  • Law News Network - Providing Latest News About The Law

  • 180 Tips - Earn Money Using Free And Accurate Football Predictions

  • Climate Change Battle - A Promising Environmental Bill Gets Crushed